On Friday January 07, 2011, Senate Education Chair, Jill Tokuda, held a Twitter Town Hall, regarding the appointed Board of Education (BOE) Legislation. This event was created to pilot the use of social media as a tool to engage the public in the policy making process.
A transcript of this event is included below. This transcript was retrieved from Senator Tokuda’s Twitter feed (@jilltokuda) and follows in descending chronological order, from the Senator’s opening to closing statements. During the event, participants’ questions were ReTweeted (RTed), also referred to as reposted, by the Senator, followed by her answer.
For ease of following the discussion, it was decided that “Q:” would be used to denote when the Senator RTed a question and “A:” would be used to denote when she answered a question (thus in the below transcript, Q: @username: followed by a question designates that the Senator is RTing an individual participant’s question. Similarly, @name followed by A: designates that the Senator is answering that individual participant’s question).
01/07/11
Senator Tokuda: Welcome to our Twitter Town Hall on the Appointed BOE! Remember to tweet w/aloha, no putdown or personal attacks. Use the #askjill tag!
Q: @raulcharvette: @jilltokuda how will we hold appointees accountable when we can’t vote them out? #askjill
Senator Tokuda: @raulcharvette A: Ultimate accountability comes w/being able to vote out the Governor & Senators doing the appointing & confirming.
Q: @eyeonhawaiigov: Do u feel that the currently elected BOE should be appointed as they were elected by the people? #askjill
Senator Tokuda: @eyeonhawaiigov A: I commend them for running, but I feel that the people ultimately voted for the Governor to appoint members.
@eyeonhawaiigov: cont-If these members would like to cont to serve, not out of the question for Governor to appoint if he chooses to
Q: RT @peterkay The con. amendment was to create more BOE accountability. will a screening cmte create more or less accountability? #askjill
Senator Tokuda: @peterkay A: Great Q! I feel screening cmte will diffuse accountability, which is why I don’t support one for the BOE process
Q: RT @gilkeithagaran What’s the thinking behind adding a screening cmte for nominees? How well has Bd of Regents process worked? #askjill
Senator Tokuda: @gilkeithagaran A: Regent’s RCAC has had issues & if we want to get the best members on BOE, need to do it differently.
Senator Tokuda: Trying to answer at least 1 question per tweeter first, will get back to add’l questions. Mahalo for your patience!
Q: RT @p_dub: any thought to a stipend for BOE appointees? Job comes with a _huge_ workload, should they be compensated? #askjill
Senator Tokuda: @p_dub A: I would support covering incidental costs re: to BOE business, similar to how other Boards such as the regents operate.
Q: RT @ryanadverderada: How can the board More easily grasp the concerns of the students if they are so far removes from individual schools?
Senator Tokuda: @ryanadverderada A: I support a voting student member on the BOE & would want us to ensure broad education-related stakeholder rep on BOE.
@ryanadverderada: cont-I also support cont to have community mtgs on each island. Perhaps could personally visit schools while there?
Senator Tokuda: Thanks! RT @fpizarro: Kudos for her Twitter Town Hall on HI’s appointed school board. Good to see public policy discussed via SM. #askjill
Q: RT @raulcharvette: Recent NYC appoint business person to run school system: Your opinion re credentials for BOE appointments? #askjill
Senator Tokuda: @raulcharvette A: BOE should have broad stakeholder rep; should also reflect diversity of student population; bring skills & exp to table
Q: RT @eyeonhawaiigov: Can the process include Senate confirmation of appointees? #askjill
Senator Tokuda: @eyeonhawaiigov A: Senate would advise & consent as w/other Board nominations.
FYI-RT @pen4rent: RT @jilltokuda @p_dub Should BOE be compensated? Are UH regents compensated? Answers: No and No. #askjill
Q: RT @gilkeithagaran: How big of a BOE? Should Legislature require or limit representation on BOE from each island/each County? #askjill
Senator Tokuda (response to @gilkeithagaran): @jilltokuda A: 11 members incl voting student; 1 per county; 6 at lrg. Allows Gov to appt more than 1 per county.
Senator Tokuda: Thanks for all the RT! Feel free to cont sending in your questions! Apologies to my FB friends for all the status updates!
Q: RT @raulcharvette: concur re ultimate accntblty;Best way to engage gov. & sens in shorter time frame, eg inputs to appointments? #askjill
Senator Tokuda: @raulcharvette A: I would hope any Gov would welcome comments/thoughts on potential appts. Senate Hrg also provides input opportunity.
Q: RT @gilkeithagaran: Shld budget from appt BOE come directly to Leg rather than screen thru @NeilAbercrombie’s bean counters? #askjill
Senator Tokuda: @gilkeithagaran A: Could make it like UH, that simultaneously sends budget req to Leg & Gov? Has never stopped them from asking directly.
Q: RT @eyeonhawaiigov: Looks like it will be set up just like all the other State Bds & Comm. How this is more acct’ble? #askjill
Senator Tokuda: @eyeonhawaiigov A: Gov can remove BOE member w/cause vs. waiting for nxt election.
[Q:] RT @raulcharvette: How will you formally influence BOE priorities; Will there be a transparent document? Public input opportunities? #askjill
Senator Tokuda: @raulcharvette A: BOE bound by sunshine laws; has public input process. That should not change
Q: RT @bytemarks: Do you have an idea how soon the Board can be selected? Will it be before the session ends? #askjill
Senator Tokuda: @bytemarks A: Ideally if Senate-House-Gov agree, we can fast track legislation; he can appt; we can confirm before session ends.
RT @eyeonhawaiigov: Gov can remove BOE member w/cause vs. waiting for nxt election Q: How do the people force the Gov to do this? #askjill
Senator Tokuda: @eyeonhawaiigov A: Many ways advocates have persuaded Gov-petitions, email campaigns, rallies, etc. Communication b/n Gov & people key.
[Q:] RT @heavygem: Thank you very much for your support of the Student BOE member with voting rights on the appointed board! #askjill
Senator Tokuda: @heavygem I have been advocating for student voting rights since I was in HS. Thank you for your advocacy & interest on this impt issue.
Q: RT @gilkeithagaran: Vetoed BOE screen cmt proposal author reportedly vying for House Speaker- have you explored bill language? #askjill
Senator Tokuda: @gilkeithagaran A: Rep Takumi was handed a draft of my bill today. We look forward to engaging House ldrshp in discussion on this measure.
Senator Tokuda: Couple more minutes to take questions or comments. Will gladly continue dialogue on FB & Twitter beyond this town hall!
Senator Tokuda: Mahalo to everyone who participated & watched all the feeds! Great comments & questions. Hope we can continue to discuss important issues!
Posted by Hawaii Senate Majority Caucus